Winter Jam Review

22 03 2010

On Saturday night, we took a busload of kids over to CenturyTel for the annual Winter Jam concert.  The entire youth group had been excited about this show for weeks: when else do you get to hear 8 or 9 major Christian bands for just $10? It was a great deal, and promised to be a night of wholesome Christian entertainment.  But by the time intermission came, I was completely disenchanted by the whole thing and found myself turning to Jordan to ask, “When did I become so cynical?”

Maybe it’s because I’m saturated in youth ministry right now, or maybe it’s because it had been a really long week, or maybe the raging liberal is coming out in me…or maybe I’m just overreacting… but I was deeply disturbed by some of the messages that were being subtly promoted by this concert tour.

Don’t get me wrong.  I do believe that the organizers of this tour have the best of intentions.  And on the whole, the evening was great: the technology was well-done, the concert flowed smoothly, and I have a lot of respect for their dedication to making this Tour affordable for all.  But it is precisely because the concert was so well-done, because there was so much hype about the Tour, and because the Tour does in fact represent the heart of Christianity to nearly 350,000 teenagers across the country, that the flaws seemed so glaring to me.  So, if anybody affiliated with Winter Jam happens to read this, please know that I respect what you do and am making these criticisms in love.  In short, these were the problems that I had with my experience on Saturday night:

1. Racism, sexism, and homophobia.  Near the beginning of the concert, one of the concert hosts was talking about how you can use music as a form of outreach.  He used the example that you could give a Christian CD to one of those Asian women at the nail salons, because you can’t understand a word they say anyway.  Jordan and I looked at each other: Did he really just say that? Out loud? I really would like to believe that he walked offstage and hit himself in the head, wondering why those words had come out of his mouth.  However, I also know that the Bossier City stop was one of the Tour’s last, and everything was extremely well-rehearsed, even a bit canned.  He had obviously said those words many times before, during many other concerts.

Equally problematic, or perhaps even more so, were featured speaker Tony Nolan‘s comments during his message (and here I paraphrase because I did not write down his exact wording): Girls, imagine that you could own all of the clothing in the world.  Wouldn’t that be great?  Guys, we don’t care so much about clothing.  Or if you do care, well, then, I’ve got to be a little bit worried about you. (cue laughter from the audience)

Okay, I know those comments aren’t exactly at the level of Westboro Baptist Church.  But that’s not the point.  How many teens in the audience were struggling with their sexuality that night?  How many of them had already been marginalized or ridiculed by the church?  Why would you ever pass up the chance to show love to these teenagers and instead make a joke about it?  It is never okay to use people’s race, ethnicity, gender, or sexuality as the butt of a joke…especially not when you are a leader in youth ministry… and especially not in a concert setting filled with thousands of impressionable Christian youth.  When you make the joke, then you are implicitly making it okay for them to go out into their churches and schools and make more jokes.

2. The Sinners’ Prayer.  This is more of a theological difference than anything, and I do want to be clear: it is not the prayer itself that I have problems with, but the hype that goes before and after it.  I take theological issue with the idea that salvation happens in a moment, but I also recognize that the organizers of the Tour probably have different theological leanings than I do, and that the inclusion of this altar-call moment was in keeping with their theology.  However, I take practical issue with the emotional and peer pressure that was put on students to “stand up if you prayed this prayer.  Come on, don’t be ashamed of your faith.”  About 30 seconds later, the speaker proudly proclaimed that several hundred  students had just made the decision to give their lives to Christ.  No further instructions were given to the students about what to do with their newly changed life, other than to stand and be counted.  I understand that they may have been short on time, but I believe they missed an opportunity to go a few notches deeper than simply “getting saved.”

3. The Mission Moment.  I would consider myself to be a pretty mission-minded person, and it takes a lot to make me criticize a missional focus.  I am all for creating experiences that challenge youth to get out of their middle-class bubble.  But I think there is a tendency in the Church to accept all things Christian as equally good, and that’s simply not the case.  As leaders especially, we must be discerning in what we choose to endorse and in how we choose to endorse it.

The featured mission organization was Holt International, an international adoption agency based out of Eugene, Oregon.  Tony Nolan spoke about his own experience of childhood abuse and said that he felt God was calling him to be the voice for children around the world.  His speech was well-done and moving.  Then, he brought to the stage his three-year-old child, whom he adopted last year, and let her speak into the microphone to say, “Help children like me.”  It was cute, for sure, but I do not believe there was any need for him to parade his child around and use her for his cause.  In 10 or 15 years, when she can speak for herself, that will be a different story.  But…maybe then she won’t bring quite the same cuteness factor onto the table.  Perhaps Tony is just a good salesman, but somehow I think I would have had less of a problem with the whole thing if he had just shown a picture of his daughter rather then handing her the microphone.

Then he asked the audience something along the lines of, “Do you believe God is calling you to be in mission?” (Who could say no?)  And the response was, “If so, then go down to Holt International‘s table and pick out a child to sponsor.  We’re trying to sponsor 200 children tonight.”  All these good, dutiful youth then streamed down to the table, ready to pick out a cute child.  Which is not the end of the world, I guess.  But I am puzzled by their choice of charities to support.  While I am aware of problems inherent in Charity Navigator‘s star-ranking system, I think it is worth noting that Holt International has only received two out of four stars and is not even included in several other ranking sites, such as the American Institute of Philanthropy.   Again, if Winter Jam is promoting excellence in all things Christian, then I believe they have the duty to think critically about the mission organization which they choose to promote.  And, I know this is just wishful thinking on my part, but I sure would love to see an event go deeper than “pick out a child that looks cute” and instead to engage deeper issues of philanthropy and mission.

Fortunately for us, the second half of the concert made up for the shortcomings of the beginning.  Tenth Avenue North was excellent, both in their music and their message.  Their songs all seem to speak to a deep sense of grace and healing, and I have continued listening to their CDs this morning :).   And the lead singer of Third Day came across as surprisingly authentic, recognizing the overwhelming consumerist nature of an event like Winter Jam while attempting to go deeper and challenge the audience to see into the heart that inspired their music.

As we left the Century Tel center and headed toward the bus, we were surprised by snow!  I guess, on the eve of spring, Winter Jam brought some winter weather to Louisiana!

Here’s some of our group on Saturday night:




5 responses

22 03 2010

I wonder… If any of these might be worth mentioning as a topic of interest with your youth— I think just the ideas about finding a credible charity is interesting and worthwhile stuff– I know it was always such a relief to hear a Christian perspective that wasn’t all about the hype– one reason I loved Epworth so much

22 03 2010

I hear your comments as being genuine concern for the kids in the audience and for the stuff they are surely wrestling with. I’m disappointed that they were faced with some of the stuff you mentioned, too. The concert I went to earlier this year that I told you about included the mission moment (for a very well-known creditable organization) and even then I remember feeling that it was not the best idea with a group of youth because of the cost involved and the disconnect of the process. I’m glad that there were some redeeming points in the second half and hope that the kids enjoyed the night of fellowship, at least.

23 03 2010

Jana — I think I just might do that. The kids are interested in being involved in some sort of child sponsorship program, and maybe we could kick it off with a discussion of how to pick an organization to give to, both individually and as a youth group. Hmmm….I’ll keep you posted…

Mama — Absolutely. I think my role as “youth director” has really made me think a lot more critically about what kinds of messages they’re receiving all the time…and how much we just let slide. They had a great time, though, and did not seem to be concerned about the things that bothered Jordan and me.

11 03 2011

I went to Winter Jam last night and was trying to find info on Holt International (reviews) when I came across your blog.

I just wanted to let you know that those racist and homophobic jokes were not made at last nights concert, so maybe he changed it up. 🙂 Who knows… maybe he read your blog! I personally felt that while Tony Nolan had a very moving story- It was a bit graphic for the many young (middle school age) children that were there. I even cringed at a few parts for my high schoolers sake. And his protrayal of adoption was VERY confusing! “My adopted parents abused me. Thank God for adoption. It is amazing.” What? Adoption is awesome. But he didn’t say anything to redeem it after telling about what happened to him.

Also, he did not bring his daughter on stage. That may have been just scheduling conflicts, but then again.. who knows! 🙂 Did his daughter have an accent? Because he told a couple stories and impersonated her with an accent. I’ve been really curious about that.

Lastly, what I found the most troubling is that this is now my 4th Christian concert (in the past few months) to not have ONE cross. Not ONE (besides the one that flashed in a movie preview, un-concert-related). What are we here for people? Despite loving their music, one of the first bands showed a Giant cool flashy light-bulb as their visual effects. What does that have to do with God? What does that have to do with Jesus Christ? I just don’t get that. The closest thing to a “religious” sign were stained glass windows (one with baby Jesus). ugh. They try so hard to not offend anyone that they become border-line secular and DO offend people. I’d rather they just took a stand, even if it didn’t fall in line with my beliefs. (I’m a Catholic Youth Minister so I know much of this stuff bugs me because it teaches my high schoolers that they can totally live a secular-Chrisitan life, which really doesn’t make sense at all. I want them to not be afraid to show the cross and to speak the truth. I would MUCH more appreciate the speaker coming out and saying, “I am Methodist and this is what I believe…” or whatever, instead of spending time on rants that just end up anti-religion and, again, borderline secular. … Jumping off my soapbox now! ha.)

Well, my husband and I did sign up for a very cute little girl named Lucille at the Holt International table, so I’m off to research them some more!!!

15 02 2016

I just attended a Winter Jam in VA and it sounds exactly like this but with some different bands (Matthew West, Crowder, Lauren Daigle……Red (metal???), Trip Lee). I am just saying me too. This concert to me was beyond disappointing as something that reaches so many people and felt like it had damaging theology. Ted Cruz and Ben Carson made campaign stops in the SC Winter Jam last weekend and it wouldn’t have been out of place here. Unfortunately. And singing God Bless America??? Smh

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: